Watcher’s Council Results – The Council Has Spoken!!

JoshuaPundit on Sep 07 2013: Alea iacta est…The Council Has Spoken!, the votes have been cast, and we have the results for this week’s Watcher’s Council match up.

“There is nothing new under the sun” – Ecclesiastes

This week’s winner, The Razor’s Obama’s Leadership Failure is a sharp, well written critique of the record of the current occupant of the White House in terms of recent history. Here’s a slice:

Over the past five years I have watched the collapse of American prestige in the world. I have come to terms with this loss, recognizing that such things are reversible and that a new administration will one day take over and reverse the decline. But as we learned during the Carter era, reinforced by Reagan’s retreat from Lebanon after 242 US Marines were killed in 1983 and later Clinton’s Somalia fiasco, such a loss resonates into the future. The prime example of this was Osama Bin Laden’s recognition of these failures as signs of America’ s loss of will, making it the “weak horse” which would collapse by the addition of a grain of salt on its back. One by one grains were added, the 1993 WTC attack, the Khobar bombings in Saudi Arabia, the Embassy Bombings of 1998, and the USS Cole attack of 2000, and the horse failed to fall. The 9-11 attacks were just more of the same, more grains of salt added to the horse’s back from Bin Laden’s perspective. But instead of collapsing under the strain Bin Laden’s metaphor collapsed, and he and his organization found itself on the defensive against a determined foe, one that eventually turned him into fish food in the Indian Ocean.

We are repeating history, and in this sequel we are much closer in time to Carter’s 1980 failed hostage rescue mission than we are to Tora Bora. President Obama’s core belief that words matter, that diplomacy can solve every crisis and that the military option is only resorted to by leaders less intelligent than himself, has been shown a failure to everyone outside his inner circle. Over the past 5 years (I include Obama’s promises in the final stage of the 2008 campaign as well as the self-importance he attached to his president-elect status after the 2008 election and before the 2009 inauguration) Obama has used promises and threats instead of deeds and action to guide US foreign policy. There was some success at first as allies took his word for the former and our enemies heeded the latter, but as the world changed the promises weren’t met and the threats weren’t acted upon, our allies became disheartened while our enemies were encouraged. Such mistakes must have come as a surprise to both, to see the most powerful and influential nation on earth run by an administration filled with the best and brightest progressive leaders the country had to offer acting like an impoverished, helpless and morally bankrupt banana republic on the world’s stage.

Nations adjusted accordingly. China has become more aggressive in its territorial claims. North Korea continues to threaten the world with nuclear annihilation with impunity. Iran has taken the success of North Korea to heart and vigorously pursues the Bomb. While the Obama administration spoke about the decimation of al Qaeda, the terrorist organization proved powerful enough to kill an American ambassador, the first in thirty years, take over leadership of the rebellion in Syria, turn Iraq into a killing zone, and scare the administration into closing a score of embassies throughout the Middle East. Not bad for an organization that the administration has said is “on the run.” Clearly al Qaeda accomplishes more in retreat than many armies do on the offensive.

Then there is Russia. It’s ironic that President Obama treats Vladimir Putin as his equal and Russia as a superpower by giving it veto power over American actions in the Middle East and throughout Asia. In effect Obama elevates the status of Russia while subverting American interests abroad. Such actions must demoralize nations in the former Russian sphere of influence like Poland and the Czech Republic, while encouraging our friends in the Middle East such as Israel and Saudi Arabia to begin to cut their own deals with Russia.

Speaking of friends, we once had one in Egypt. It was a typical Middle Eastern friend. It took gobs of money from us then fed the masses a steady diet of anti-American propaganda that encouraged Islamic terrorism. But the Egyptian regime was successful for the most part. It kept itself in power, maintained the peace – albeit a cold one – with Israel, and kept the foreign currency flowing into Egypt from European and American tourists. Make no mistake Hosni Mubarak was no Winston Churchill, and the Egyptian regime never had our back the way Australia always has, but to expect anything more from Arabs in the Middle East requires complete ignorance of the culture and history of the area. Nevertheless the Obama administration and the State Department under the leadership of Hillary Clinton, a woman whose resume highlight for the job included hosting dinners as the First Lady in the White House for eight years, proved through their actions (and inactions) that for all their supposed brilliance, they were at heart as dumb as a box of blocks when it came to Egypt.

Council Winners

*First place with 3 votes! The Razor – Obama’s Leadership Failure
Second place with 2 2/3 votes – Joshuapundit – The Saudis Look At Dumping Obama And Changing Sponsors
Third place with 2 votes – The Right Planet – Syria-pocrisy
Fourth place *t* with 1 vote – Bookworm Room – As a Jew, why am I not more exercised about the use of poison gas in Syria?
Fourth place *t* with 1 vote – Liberty’s Spirit – The World? is “Offended” by the Use of Chemical Weapons…UPDATED
Fourth place *t* with 1 vote – The Political Commentator – Obama must have missed Coalition Building 101 at president school!
Fifth place *t* with 1/3 vote – Simply Jews – The Realpolitik Of “to bomb or not to bomb”: Isn’t There Something Else That Matters?
Fifth place *t* with 1/3 vote – Nice Deb – Nobel Peace Prize Winning Citizen of the World President Willing to Go It Alone On Bombing Syria

Non-Council Winners

First place with 3 votes! – The Elder Of Ziyon – Bashar Assad’s grandfather’s amazing 1936 letter to France submitted by Simply Jews
Second place with 2 votes – Michael Yon – Syria Outrage Is Not a Strategy submitted by The Glittering Eye
Third place *t* with 1 1/3 votes – The Diplomad 2.0 – From Cowboy to Mau-Mau Diplomacy submitted by Joshuapundit
Third place *t* with 1 1/3 votes –David Gerstman/Le·gal In·sur·rec·tion – Is There no Limit to the Administration’s Cynicism Regarding Israel? submitted by The Watcher
Fourth place with 1 vote – Sister Toldjah – Photo of the Day: @AnthonyWeiner poses with “The Big Salami” – submitted by Rhymes With Right
Fifth place *t* with 2/3 votes – Via Meadia – The President’s Decision submitted by Liberty’s Spirit
Fifth place *t* with 2/3 vote – American Thinker – Mideast Nuclear Holocaust submitted by The Political Commentator
Fifth place *t* with 2/3 vote –PJ Media/Barry Rubin – Turning Point: Obama and Israel, the Next Three Years submitted by Bookworm Room
Fifth place *t* with 2/3 vote –Douglas Ernst – Will Nobel Peace Prize winner Obama spark a world war with a strike on Syria? – submitted by The Colossus of Rhodey
Sixth place *t* with 1/3 vote –Air Force Magazine – 2nd Coming of Counterinsurgency submitted by GrEaT sAtAn”S gIrLfRiEnD

Honorable Mentions

The Independent Sentinel – Common Sense and a Fundamentally Transformed United States
Ask Marion – Ostriches or Eagles
The Pirate’s Cove – How To Destroy The Morals And Mores Of A Country

See you next week! Don’t forget to tune in on Monday AM for this week’s Watcher’s Forum, as the Council and their invited special guests take apart one of the provocative issues of the day with short takes and weigh in…don’t you dare miss it. And don’t forget to like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter…..’cause we’re cool like that!