What Movies in History Best Captures the Spirit of Thanksgiving?

It’s a Wonderful Life – The annual ritual of watching Frank Capra’s 1946 holiday movie classic on Thanksgiving, kicking off the Christmas season, didn’t gain currency until the 1980s

Yahoo: “In the last 40 years, if you said a character named Captain Christopher Jones would be a figurehead in a movie about the first Thanksgiving, those born within that time frame would think it was the name of the protagonist in a romantic comedy taking place on Thanksgiving. Such is the shift of themes in Hollywood over the decades in movies that represent the meaning of Thanksgiving or the days surrounding late November. However, finding one Thanksgiving movie that captures the true spirit of the holiday is ultimately based on your personal cinematic perceptions.”

One thing we can say: There never has been a movie set on Thanksgiving that doesn’t have some kind of discord or other tribulation for the sake of watchable plot. This doesn’t necessarily mean that those plots didn’t eventually include some type of comedy before arguably becoming sentimental at the end to remind you it’s the holidays. Yet what about those early movies I referenced above that depicted the meaning of Thanksgiving?

Earliest Hollywood didn’t make movies taking place on Thanksgiving, perhaps because there was a contentious political battle over when the holiday took place. For those seeing "Lincoln" this weekend, (Team of Rivals – Lincoln Film Tie-In Edition.  Also Killing Lincoln is a must read) consider the irony in Honest Abe once setting a long precedent for Thanksgiving being recognized during the final Thursday of November.

In 1939, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt unofficially moved Thanksgiving to the previous Thursday. At the eve of World War II, FDR’s more commercial stance led to a (surprise!) bitter battle between Republicans and Democrats over when Thanksgiving should officially be celebrated.

Yes, that Congressional story could be a Thanksgiving movie on its own in the future. But after that initial political event was federally settled in 1942, Hollywood only briefly took Thanksgiving commercial with "Miracle on 34th Street" five years later. By 1952, Hollywood went sacred with "Plymouth Adventure [Remaster] {VHS}", starring Spencer Tracy as Captain Christopher Jones of the Mayflower. As you’d expect, it was partially fiction, though set a reverent cinematic tone for Thanksgiving that didn’t change until the 1980s.

What was it that changed in the 1980s that led to a few films finally being set on Thanksgiving? Perhaps it was the greed mentality of the era and the beginnings of Black Friday as we know it today. Doing so romanticized this time of year to the point where many romantic comedies started being set on Thanksgiving or around the holidays. Just take a look at how it influenced Woody Allen with 1986’s "Hannah and Her Sisters."

Hollywood even toyed with an odd horror movie genre where something slightly morose takes place on Thanksgiving weekend. That genre has recurred periodically since the 1980s with such films as “Home Sweet Home" and more recent "Boogeyman." However, these didn’t provide one particular magic formula for audiences: Comedy.

Those wanting a more cheerful diversion should go for this Steve Martin and John Candy comedy. When finding one movie that represents Thanksgiving better than any other in the modern era, it has to be 1987’s "Planes, Trains and Automobiles." In fact, it set a comedy pattern that’s been copied right up through the 2010s with much less success. Martin stars as Neal Page, a highly strung advertising man who’s forced to go on an adventure with Candy’s Del Griffith, an easygoing talkative curtain ring salesman due them trying to get Neal home to Chicago from New York in time for Thanksgiving.

If you call it holiday black comedy, it still represents travel during the Thanksgiving in a way that forever brings guffaw communion. And it has a relationship story, plus a sentimental ending. Hence, it officiates this film as capturing the full spirit of a modern Thanksgiving.

Then again, that love triangle among Captain Jones, William Bradford, and Dorothy Bradford in "Plymouth Adventure [Remaster] {VHS}" comes close to unintended holiday romanticism.

1995 brought us the modern Thanksgiving reality themed movies The War at Home and Home for the Holidays.  The War at Home is a real family affair, with Emilio Estevez and his legendary father Martin Sheen. Estevez directed the film, served as co-producer as well as co-starring with his dad. Estevez plays Jeremy Collier, a Vietnam War hero who struggles to return to civilian life in a small town after his experiences in a war zone. Home for the Holidays stars Holly Hunter, Robert Downey Jr., Anne Bancroft, Charles Durning, Dylan McDermott, Geraldine Chaplin, Steve Guttenberg, Cynthia Stevenson with Claire Danes, ‘Home For The Holidays follows Claudia Larson, a single-mom who’s just lost her job and flies home to meet her family; crazy antics, lessons learned and newfound relationships make this a turkey-filled classic.

Then there is The Ice Storm (1997) set during Thanksgiving 1973, Ang Lee’s 1997 movie, based on the novel by Rick Moody. Starring Kevin Cline, Joan Allen, Sigourney Weaver, Tobey Maguire, Christina Ricci and Elijah Wood, the movie follows two interlinked Connecticut families breaking apart as the children discover adulthood and the adults regress to childhood. This angst ridden classic may not be one to cheer you up if the turkey’s gone awry but it’s thrilling delving into suburban disintegration, sexual experimentation and the titular weather disaster make it a dark holiday classic. The film also featured Katie Holmes screen debut.

Pieces of April (2003) starring a pre-TomKat Katie Holmes,  follows April Burns, a young woman from a dysfunctional family who invites her estranged folks over for Thanksgiving. There follows a variety of misadventures, but all learn that whatever happens, at this time of year it’s family that matters.

Sometimes watching an old movie with relatives or your kids is a great place to start a conversation about society, changes in our culture, history, tradition or even faith that can lead to future conversations, the reading and reviewing of books and expanded conversations.


Merry Christmas From Hollywood – Holiday Movie Classics

God Rest Ye Merry Merchants

Ben Stein on Christmas

How to avoid grinches at Christmas

For Fourth Straight Year, Obama’s Thanksgiving Message Doesn’t Thank God

A National Crisis in Character… So Let Us Recapture The Culture!

Happy Thanksgiving! President Abraham Lincoln’s Thanksgiving Proclamation of 1863 Called the Nation to Give Thanks to God

About Ask Marion

I am a babyboomer and empty nester who savors every moment of my past and believes that it is the responsibility of each of us in my generation and Americans in general to make sure that America is as good or even a better place for future generations as it was for us. So far... we haven't done very well!! Favorite Quotes: "The first 50 years are to build and acquire; the second 50 are to leave your legacy"; "Do something that scares you every day!"; "The journey in between what you once were and who you are becoming is where the dance of life really takes place". At age 62 I find myself fighting inoperable uterine Cancer and thanks to the man upstairs and the prayers from so many people including many of my readers from AskMarion and JustOneMorePet... I'm beating it. After losing our business because of the economy and factors related to the re-election of President Obama in 2012 followed by 16-mos of job hunting, my architect-trained husband is working as a trucker and has only been home approximately 5-days a month since I was diagnosed, which has made everything more difficult and often lonely... plus funds are tight. Our family medical deductible is 12K per year for two of us; thank you ObamaCare. But thanks to donations from so many of you, we are making ends meet as I go through treatment while taking care of my father-in-law who is suffering from late stage Alzheimer's and my mother-in-law who suffers from RA and onset dementia as well as hearing loss, for which there are no caretaker funds, as I continue the fight here online to inform and help restore our amazing country. And finally I need to thank a core group of family, friends, and readers... all at a distance, who check in with me regularly. Plus, I must thank my furkids who have not left my side through this fight. You can see them at JustOneMorePet.
This entry was posted in Books, Common Sense, Communication, Entertainment, Family and Friends, Holidays, Knowledge Is Power, Remembering, Tradition, Wisdom, You Be the Judge and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

31 Responses to What Movies in History Best Captures the Spirit of Thanksgiving?

  1. Pingback: The War on Christmas verses the Spirit of Christmas Series at AskMarion | askmarion

  2. Pingback: Advent – The Season of Anticipation and Hope | askmarion

  3. Pingback: God Rest Ye Merry Merchants – Christmas: An American Holiday and Tradition to Love and Preserve | askmarion

  4. Pingback: Best Holiday Movie Classics – A Merry Christmas From Hollywood | askmarion

  5. Pingback: So Where Is the War on Christmas Coming From? – A Worthwhile Read! | askmarion

  6. Pingback: St. Nickolas Day | askmarion

  7. Pingback: European Markets or Christkindlmarkts Capture the Christmas Spirit | askmarion

  8. Pingback: Hanukkah, Hanukah, Chanukah | askmarion

  9. Pingback: Christmas Trees | askmarion

  10. Pingback: Nativity – The Reason for the Season | askmarion

  11. Pingback: Carolling… or Caroling and Christmas Music | askmarion

  12. Pingback: NewsWeek and Jon Stewart Decree the War on Christmas is Over… | askmarion

  13. Pingback: Christmas Baking | askmarion

  14. Pingback: War on Christmas is Part of the Overall War on Religion… a Move Toward a ‘New Age’ – a NWO with a One World Religion and Often From Within Churches | askmarion

  15. Pingback: American Traditions | askmarion

  16. Pingback: Christmas for Pet People | askmarion

  17. Pingback: The Best Part of the Christmas Season – Love, Charity, and Kindness | askmarion

  18. Pingback: Santa Photos… Often Yesterday’s Oooops Are Tomorrow’s Treasures! | askmarion

  19. Pingback: The Best Christmas Gifts | askmarion

  20. Pingback: Christmas Lights | askmarion

  21. Pingback: Remembering the Military and Christmastime | askmarion

  22. Pingback: Simpler Times – A Groetzmeier Christmas | askmarion

  23. Pingback: Ronald Reagan Christmas Address (video) | askmarion

  24. Pingback: Merry Christmas From Ask Marion | askmarion

  25. Pingback: The 2nd Day of Christmas–St. Stephen’s Day, Boxing Day and Wenceslaus | askmarion

  26. Pingback: The Meaning of Epiphany | askmarion

  27. Pingback: Movie Legends Who Failed To Take Home Oscar Gold | askmarion

  28. Pingback: American Culture: a Civilization Gone with the Wind—Thanks to the Left’s Secret Civil War | askmarion

  29. Pingback: Forum: How does your family traditionally celebrate Thanksgiving? | askmarion

  30. Pingback: Obama Thanksgiving Disgrace | askmarion

  31. Pingback: Happy Thanksgiving and Thank You to All Our Readers for Your Support from Ask Marion | askmarion

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s